Real Estate Agents in Big Pine Key, FL
72 licensed local agents serving Big Pine Key — every license verified against the state register. Compare them, or get matched to the best fit in seconds. It costs you nothing.
Agents serving Big Pine Key
Big Pine Key real estate agents at a glance
72 licensed real estate agents serve Big Pine Key, from the Florida license register. 20 of them (28%) hold a broker license. The typical agent here has been licensed about 10.9 years, and 41 have ten years or more. 6 were licensed in the past twelve months, so ask how many Big Pine Key deals an agent has closed, not only how long they have held a license.
The typical Big Pine Key home is worth $752,866 (+3.6% in a year), per the Zillow Home Value Index for September 2026. See the Big Pine Key housing market →
Firms with the most agents in Big Pine Key
- Coldwell Banker Schmitt Real Estate Co15 agents
- Keyisle Real Estate LLC7 agents
- Langley Knight Gardner LLC4 agents
- Island Welcome Real Estate LLC3 agents
- Action Keys Realty of the Lower Florida Keys LLC2 agents
Nearby cities
All licensed agents in Big Pine Key
72 licensed agents in Big Pine Key on the state register. Those with a profile on Homegrity are listed A–Z by name, 100 to a page. This is the register, not the ranked list above — nobody can pay to appear here or to move up it.
- Erendira Arguelles
- Bruce Ball
- Cheryl Billings
- Scott Brisson
- Alecia Brumley
- Ceballos, Walter a PA
- Cheryl Christ
- Michael Coppola Jr.
- Christina Davis
- Rose Dell
- Mara Demauro-Mazzacane
- Dietrick, Anneliese LLC
- Sandra Dolowy
- Armando Lambert
- Armando Lambert
- Armando Lambert
- William Dover
- Ross Downes
- Bo Ek
- Kasey Fey
- Gernaat, Ryan LLC
- Juan Gonzalez
- Melissa Graham
- Elizabeth Degrenier
- Haack, Karen PA
- Susan Halligan
- Halstead, Donna Lynn LLC
- Lara Hanousek
- Deni Heintzelman
- Shannon Heinze
- Kaufmann, David M. PA
- Patricia Kersey
- Jaime Kulaga
- Wesley Kulaga
- Ida Lea
- Karen Liskey
- Dunia McClain
- Kevin Madok
- Bonnie Madrid
- Mauriello, Dorothy L. PA
- Kaylee Moore
- Cheryl Moses
- Carmen Myers
- Nazzaro, John PA
- Patricia Nickless
- William Nickless
- Christina Parker
- Kylie Perry
- Mark Peterson
- Aimex Pillow
- Taia Pinholster
- Anthony Polizze
- Eva Polizze
- Anne Press
- Prevatt, Banks PA
- Stephen Prieto
- Rogers, Paul L. PA
- Richard Rosa
- Christine Rudy
- Salvatore, John LLC
- Sanders, Lee R. PA
- Sunnie Lorenzo
- Stacy Shahan
- Kaitlin Shew
- Teresa Horachek
- Jon Stowers
- John Takovich
- Thoman-Wood, Tara PA
- Ronda Threlkeld
- Nira Tocco
- Caroline Earles
- Thuy Watler
Why work with a local Big Pine Key agent
They price from real comps
Local Big Pine Key sold data, not an online estimate, sets the right number — whether you're making an offer or listing your home.
They know the neighborhoods
Schools, commutes, and which streets command a premium vary block to block; a Big Pine Key specialist reads those nuances instantly.
They negotiate where it counts
The right offer terms, the inspection findings that actually matter, and the local customs that win deals.
They run the whole process
Lender, inspector, title, deadlines — a great local agent keeps it all on track to closing.
How to choose the right agent in Big Pine Key
Interview more than one, ask for recent Big Pine Key closings in your price range, and ask how they handled problems on past deals. Our guide to choosing a real estate agent lists the exact questions to ask, and the buyer's hub and seller's hub cover what comes next.
Frequently asked questions about Big Pine Key agents
How many real estate agents are there in Big Pine Key, FL?
72 licensed real estate agents serve Big Pine Key, according to the Florida license register; 20 of them hold a broker license. Every license is verified against the state register.
Which real estate firms have the most agents in Big Pine Key?
By licensed agents placed in Big Pine Key: Coldwell Banker Schmitt Real Estate Co (15), Keyisle Real Estate LLC (7), Langley Knight Gardner LLC (4). The biggest firm is not always the best fit; compare individual agents on this page.
How do I find a good real estate agent in Big Pine Key?
Look for an agent who actively works Big Pine Key — recent local closings, client reviews, and fast communication matter far more than a big national name. Every agent on this page has a license verified against the state register: compare them here, or get matched free in seconds.
Who is the best real estate agent in Big Pine Key?
No agent can pay for placement on Homegrity. The right agent depends on what you need: the area, the type of home and your timing. Tell us and we'll match you free with licensed agents who work Big Pine Key.
How much does a real estate agent cost in Big Pine Key?
For buyers and sellers, using Homegrity to find and get matched with a Big Pine Key agent is completely free, with no obligation. Commissions on a sale are negotiated separately and paid at closing — your agent will explain exactly how that works for your situation.
What does Homegrity check about Big Pine Key agents?
Every agent on this page has a license verified against the state register. We do not hold sales records, so we do not claim to check them.
How are the Big Pine Key agents on this page ordered?
Agents are ordered by Homegrity Score. Today that score comes only from the state license register — license status, how long they have been licensed, and whether the state names their firm — because that is what we can verify. No one can pay to appear higher.
Can I get matched with a Big Pine Key agent for free?
Absolutely. Answer a few quick questions and we'll match you with the best-fit local agent for your goals — free, private, and no agent hears from you until you ask. Not the right fit? Re-match in one tap.
Not sure who's right for you?
Answer a few quick questions and we'll match you with the Big Pine Key agent who fits your goals — with the reasons why.
Find my agent